Money Trap – Not All Supermarket Sales Are Created Equal

by Chaz on November 1, 2008

We all love the thrill of getting a great deal. A sense of pride overwhelms us when we get 50% off a purchase. Yet, grocery stores have learned how to play this love for the deal against us.

They have conditioned us to expect a great bargain whenever we pick up an item that has a bright red sale sign in front of it. But as we’ll see this habit can be dangerous to our wallet.

Let’s take a look at a basket of goods that an average shopper might purchase:
shredded cheese, cookies, waffles, orange juice, syrup, cereal, ravioli, trash bags, and spaghetti.

All of these items were recently on sale at a suburban Chicago supermarket. Now if we take a closer look we see that we did indeed get a great deal on some of our products.

Product Original Price Sales Price Percent Savings
15 oz Chef Boyardee Beef Ravioli $2 $1 50%
16 oz Nabisco Oreo Cookies $4.49 $2.50 44%
16 oz O-BRAND Organic Spaghetti $2.19 $1.09 50%
8 oz Kraft Shredded Cheddar Cheese $4.99 $2.50 50%


We saved between 44% – 50% on each of these items. Truly great deals. But lets take a look at some of the other sale items in our basket.

Product Original Price Sales Price Percent Savings
64 oz Florida’s Natural Orange Juice $4.49 $3.99 11%
24 oz Ms. Butterworth Sugar Free Syrup $4.59 $4.09 11%
17 oz Kelloggs Fruit Loops $4.99 $4.49 10%


The savings now don’t look so great. Only 10% – 11% savings. The savings on the rest of the goods in our basket were even worse.

Product Original Price Sales Price Percent Savings
40 ct – 1 gallon Glad Trash Bags $3.99 $3.79 5%
8 ct Kelloggs Cereal Snack Packs $3.99 $3.79 5%


On these items we saved a measly 5% and quite frankly a 5% savings is hardly worth the effort.

The lesson …. Before you instinctively pick up a sale item, compare the sale price with the original price to see if you’re truly getting a great deal. If you can’t save at least 30%, put the “sale” item right back on the shelf.

Related Articles

Leave a Comment

Previous post: The Theme Display – A Grocery Store Money Trap

Next post: Save Money by Editing Your Grocery Cart